Yoast vs All in One SEO Pack: Comparison, Analysis, and Answers

Yoast vs All in One SEO Pack: Comparison, Analysis, and Answers

SEO is important for practically anyone who has a website. But properly configuring a site for SEO is not an easy task. CMS WordPress makes this process much easier.

Many plugins solve particular SEO problems. There are two main types, SEO Yoast and One SEO pack.

What is an SEO-Plugin?

It is difficult for a beginner to understand all of the settings, which is what SEO-plugins are for. With their help, you can make basic SEO settings in 2-3 clicks. But there is not one SEO plugin that will be able to write quality thematic content for you or correct specific technical errors on the site. This means that you should not rely solely on SEO plugins for setting up the site, they will only help you to manage basic tasks more quickly. 

Thus, it is necessary to work with SEO independently. To understand which SEO plugin is better, it is important to know what a good SEO plugin is and what tasks it does:

  • It allows you to make technical changes to the website without interfering with the code.
  • It does not have extra features that are not important for SEO promotion.
  • The plugin takes the latest SEO updates into account and responds to them. This is very important since search engines are constantly changing their algorithms.
  • The plugin is simple and easy to configure.
  • It does not conflict with other plugins or the site theme.
  • It does not slow down the site.

What is All in One SEO Pack Plugin?

Features:

  • Google AMP Support
  • Easy integration with Google Analytics
  • Extended Canonical Support
  • Supports XML Sitemap
  • Helps avoid duplicate pages
  • Compatible with other plugins
  • The ability to configure metadata in bulk
  • Integration with WooCommerce

What is SEO Yoast?

SEO analysis of the page content Features:

  • Mass editing of metadata by template (an ideal solution for online stores)
  • XML Sitemap
  • Editors robots.txt and .htaccess
  • Integration with social networks
  • RSS
  • “Breadcrumbs”
  • Canonical installation
  • URL Settings

How do I Configure the All in One SEO Pack and SEO Yoast Plugins?

You cannot just install and activate SEO plugins on WordPress. It is important to configure them correctly. 

For detailed instructions on setting up SEO Yoast and All in One SEO Pack, refer to our article:

Setting up SEO Plugins on WordPress: Yoast and All in One Seo

SEO Yoast or All in One SEO Pack: a Comparison of Technical Settings and Features

Now, let’s move onto the main point of this article and determine which plugin is better. Let’s use the most important criteria to compare the two plugins: technical, content analysis, usability, etc. After each comparison, we will decide which plugin is the winner for the round and tally the points on a table.

Sitemap

This is a critical setting that helps search engines index the site correctly.

Yoast SEO

The settings are quite limited. There is no way to set the update frequency and priority. You do have the ability to delete pages.

All in One SEO Pack

The All in One SEO Pack sitemap is much better: 

  • You can set the update frequency
  • It is possible to set the priority of pages
  • Scheduled update
  • You can create an RSS feed
  • You can delete pages

Conclusion

The All in One SEO Pack is the winner.

Robots.txt

Robots tell search engines which pages should not be indexed. The robots file can be created in both plugins.

Yoast SEO

All in One SEO Pack

Conclusion

It is a tie.

Indexing

A webmaster must be able to close pages from indexing via meta robots. Both plug-ins provide this feature.

Yoast SEO

All in One SEO Pack

Conclusion

It is a tie.

Canonical Setup

Canonical is the best way to avoid duplicate sites. Yoast SEO and All in One SEO Pack create this setting for all pages by default and it is possible to change the canonical for each page.

Yoast SEO

The plug-in automatically enables Canonical.

All in One SEO Pack

Here you can choose whether or not to enable Canonical.

Conclusion

It is a tie.

Numbering Pages

Sorting pages are usually closed from indexing through meta robots and linked by a prev next chain.

Yoast SEO

Older versions of this plug-in made it possible to easily close all page numbering pages from indexing with two clicks.

This feature was removed in the latest versions for some reason. To configure, look for the plug-in version 3.3.4.

All in One SEO Pack

It is possible to close pagination pages, but I can tell you from personal experience that this function does not always work. For example, a plug-in can block the indexing of pagination pages in a blog, but the numbering pages of a product catalog will still be open for indexing.

Conclusion

Both plug-ins are unstable in this function; therefore, it is a tie. 

URL Setting

Proper page URL settings are very important for SEO. They should not be long or contain a lot of unnecessary characters. There should not be any Latin letters.

Yoast SEO

You can remove /category/ in the plug-in, which can make the category pages slightly shorter. Enabling this feature is optional.

You can also change the URLs of individual posts and pages.

All in One SEO Pack

This plug-in does not have a URL editing function.

Conclusion

Yoast SEO is the winner.

Redirects

Redirects are a great way to deal with broken links.

Yoast SEO

This plug-in allows you to configure redirects directly from the admin panel.

All in One SEO Pack

This plug-in cannot control redirects.

Conclusion

Yoast SEO is the winner.

 “Breadcrumbs”

They improve the usability and linking of the site. 

Yoast SEO

With this plug-in, you can configure the output of the “Breadcrumbs”.

All in One SEO Pack

The All in One SEO Pack does not offer this feature.

Conclusion

The winner of this round is Yoast SEO.

Configuring RSS

This feature is especially important for media sites. It is an RSS feed that is sent to various news aggregators.

Yoast SEO

In Yoast SEO, you can create an RSS feed.

All in One SEO Pack

In the All in One SEO Pack, you can create an RSS Sitemap.

Conclusion

It is a draw.

SEO Yoast and All in One SEO Pack: Which plug-in Is Better for Optimizing Content and Metadata?

Optimizing content and metadata is a key task for a webmaster. Which plug-in is better at this?

Content Analysis

It is important to understand that the quality of content is primarily determined by its readability and usefulness, not by plug-in recommendations. Therefore, the recommendations given by plug-ins should be treated only as advice. Meticulously implementing plug-in edits will not give you a significant advantage in the search results if the content is not valuable.

Yoast SEO

Yoast SEO provides a fairly detailed analysis of the page content. There are also precise recommendations on how to improve it.

All in One SEO Pack

The All in One SEO Pack does not analyze page content.

Conclusion

Yoast SEO is the winner.

Is the Mass Customization of Title and Description Available?

Being able to configure metadata in bulk is extremely important for online stores and sites with services. Every webmaster should be able to use a template to configure the metadata of the product or service pages.

Yoast SEO

The ability to massively customize is much better implemented because you can see a snippet immediately.

All in One SEO Pack

You can only configure the title, plus snippets are not available. 

Conclusion

Yoast SEO is the winner.

SEO Yoast vs All in One SEO Pack: Social Media Integration

Yoast allows you to display structured information on Twitter, Facebook, Pinterest, and Google+. Also, Rel Published and Author markup are available.

The All in One SEO Pack team has focused on Facebook and Twitter.

Conclusion

Yoast SEO wins this round.

Which Plug-in Can Be Configured Faster, Yoast SEO or All in One SEO Pack?

One of the main reasons for downloading an SEO plug-in is the time that it can save. In this matter, the choice between All in One and Yoast is not so simple. Both plugins save you a lot of time.

But, when it comes to implementing a lot of fixes, All in One is the clear winner. If you are starting the site from scratch and it needs major SEO changes as quickly as possible, All in One offers the most convenient way to fix errors.

Conclusion

The winner is the All in One SEO Pack.

Which Plugin Is Easier for a Beginner to Work With?

When using Yoast, users should understand that not all of the options are on the same screen. You need to review a lot of guides to find the right settings. At the same time, the Yoast interface is very convenient.

However, the All in One SEO is 100% the winner on this matter.

The main reasons being:

  • The ability to edit metadata without going to the page itself.
  • Most of the settings are on one page.

Conclusion

The winner is the All in One SEO Pack.

SEO Yoast or All in One SEO Pack: Which Has Better Tech Support?

When it comes to customer support, both plugins are on the same level. Neither plugin provides technical support for those who are using the free download.

However, they both offer personalized customer support for those who purchase the premium version.

Conclusion

It is a tie.

Comparison of Premium Versions

Yoast SEO Premium Version

The basic free version of Yoast SEO has all the necessary functionality to take your site’s SEO to a new level. However, the disadvantage is the lack of online support. You can post a question on the topic forums, but no one can guarantee that you will get an answer.

The premium version of the plugin has a support feature that answers questions in less than 30 minutes. How much does Yoast SEO cost? An annual subscription starts at $69 for one site and goes up to $799 for 100 sites.

In addition to the support, Yoast SEO Premium offers an additional option to access SEO video tutorials.

Additionally, the Yoast team offers these SEO add-ons for various areas:

  • Video SEO (starts at $69) – it helps your channel earn a high position on Google.
  • Local SEO (starts at $69) – this is an option for local businesses that is designed to improve positions in the regional search.
  • News SEO (starts at $69)- to optimize your site for Google News.
  • WooCommerce SEO (starts at $49) – for online stores based on WooCommerce.

You can also get Yoast SEO premium and all the add-ons included for $279. The license is only issued for one site.

All in One SEO Pack Premium Version

The All in One SEO Pack plugin has fewer packages already prepared. The plugin team bid to add some rare features:

  • Support for Google Tag Manager
  • SEO module for images
  • Improved SEO for categories and filter pages
  • SEO module for video
  • Access to a premium knowledge base and forums

There are three packages to choose from.

Conclusion

The offers from the Yoast SEO team look much more interesting. Offering additional settings for different types of businesses is a very good solution.

Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO Pack: Which One Is More Profitable?

The All in One SEO Pack is cheaper but less functional. The price difference between the two plugins is minimal. Therefore, Yoast SEO is a better investment in this situation.

Many inexperienced webmasters try to enable Yoast SEO and the All in One SEO Pack simultaneously to get maximum results. But unfortunately, this can bring about various technical errors and slow the site down.Can I Use 2 SEO Plugins?

Even the plugins themselves hint at this. If you enable two plugins at once, you will immediately see suggestions to transfer data.

The Disadvantages of SEO Yoast and All in One SEO Pack

Disadvantages of Yoast SEO

  • Since the settings are on different pages it is difficult to configure.
  • It takes a long time to set up correctly.

Disadvantages of All in One SEO Pack

  • Fewer opportunities for technical SEO optimization.
  • Fewer features for content optimization.
  • Fewer settings in the premium version.

The Benefits of SEO Yoast and All in One SEO Pack

Advantages of SEO Yoast over All in One SEO Pack 

  • More opportunities for SEO content optimization.
  • More options for technical optimization.
  • The premium version offers interesting features.

Advantages of All in One SEO Pack over SEO Yoast 

  • It is more suitable for beginners.
  • It is quickly configured.

How do I Transfer Settings Quickly?

If after reading this article, you have decided to change plugins, all of your settings can easily be automatically transferred.

Transferring settings from the All in One SEO Pack to Yoast SEO

  • Enable the import and export module.

  • Select the desired settings and click “export”. Save the derived file.

  • Enable the Yoast SEO plugin and to the “tools” section. In the “Import” tab you can add a previously created file.

  • You can import settings without shutting down the old plugin. To do this, go to the section “Import from other SEO plugins”.

Transferring Settings from Yoast SEO to All in One SEO Pack

  • Create a file in the “Export” tab.

  • Enable the All in One SEO Pack plugin and upload a previously created file in the “Import and Export” section, after activating this module. Next, click on the “import” button.

Conclusion on All in One SEO Pack vs Yoast: Which WordPress Plugin Is Better for SEO?

WordPress SEO Optimization

Both parties did a fantastic job. After analyzing, I can give advice:

  • SEO beginners should try the All in One SEO Pack first.
  • For more experienced professionals, I recommend Yoast SEO.

The winner of my comparison is Yoast SEO. I use the old version of Yoast SEO 3.3.4 on all of my sites. For me, this plugin is indispensable when working with any WordPress site.


I hope that this article helped you make a decision.Yoast SEO and the All in One SEO Pack are great plugins for SEO site optimization. But the main thing to remember is that they do not solve all problems. To improve the traffic and positions, you need to constantly work on improving the content and correct technical errors on time.

Author

Igor Kurochkin Igor Kurochkin

Igor is a SEO specialist and webmaster since 2013. Certified Analytics Specialist.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *